ResourcesAlternative equity 101

Long-Term Cash Awards in the MARE, Explained

What exactly is a long-term cash award and how does it differ from phantom stock and profit sharing?

April 21, 2024
5 min read

At Reins, we’ve often explained MARE Profit (profit sharing) as a short-term employee incentive and MARE Stock (phantom stock) as a long-term employee incentive. But there is another deferred compensation benefit in the mix: the long-term cash award.

Comparison to Phantom Stock and Profit Sharing

A long-term cash award pays cash on terms fixed in advance, such as a date, a performance goal or a share of salary, while phantom stock pays an amount that moves with the value of the company. Both reward key staff for staying, but only phantom stock rises and falls with the business. Here is how they compare:

Phantom stock
  • A promise for future cash that is most often linked to the value of the company’s actual or hypothetical stock.
  • The value of the cash payout is variable, as the value of the company can increase or decrease at the time of payout.
  • Helpful in cultivating an owner-like mentality in employees, since the value of their individual stock award is tied to the company’s success, similar to that of a shareholder.
Long-term cash award
  • A promise for future cash that has nothing to do with the value of the company and is instead tied to a certain time period, performance goal, or percentage of salary.
  • The value of the cash payout is defined upfront.
  • Helpful in incentivizing an employee to stick around for a defined period of time; for example, until a project is completed or until a certain number of years have passed after a company has been sold.

Profit sharing, on the other hand, is easier to differentiate since it is a short-term bonus plan that is most frequently paid out quarterly or annually.

What Does A Long-Term Cash Award Look Like In The Modern Agreement For Rewards And Equity?

In the Modern Agreement for Rewards and Equity, an owner can grant each employee either phantom equity or a long-term cash award, but not both. A long-term cash award can be set up in one of four ways, and each one sets how the payout is worked out before the employee earns it:

  1. Setting aside a predefined dollar amount per year while the employee remains with the company.
  2. A percentage of the employee’s base salary to be awarded annually.
  3. A percentage of the employee’s salary multiplied by the ratio between the company’s annual net profit to its budgeted net profit.
  4. A custom input.

Owners can choose from a variety of payment triggers (similar to phantom stock) or choose a fixed payment schedule.

Long-Term Cash Award FAQs

What is a long-term cash award?

A promise of set cash later, on fixed terms. A long-term cash award pays an employee an amount tied to a time period, a performance goal or a percentage of salary. Unlike phantom stock, the payout does not move with the value of the company.

How is a long-term cash award different from phantom stock?

Phantom stock moves with company value; a cash award does not. Phantom stock pays cash linked to the value of the company's actual or hypothetical stock, so it rises and falls with the business, while a long-term cash award defines its value upfront. Phantom stock builds an owner-like mindset, and a long-term cash award keeps someone through a defined period.

Can an employee get both phantom stock and a long-term cash award?

No, it is one or the other. In the Reins Modern Agreement for Rewards and Equity, a small business owner grants each employee either phantom equity or a long-term cash award, but not both. The choice comes down to whether you want the reward to track the value of the company.

How is a long-term cash award taxed?

It can fall under Section 409A deferred compensation rules. Because it defers pay, a long-term cash award can count as nonqualified deferred compensation under Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code, which limits payment to events such as separation from service, a fixed schedule or a change in control. A plan that breaks those rules leaves the employee owing tax on the deferred amount plus a 20 percent additional tax and interest, so have a tax adviser review it.

When does a long-term cash award pay out?

When the trigger the owner chose is met. Owners can pick from a variety of payment triggers, as with phantom stock, or set a fixed payment schedule. Common examples are a set number of years of service, the completion of a project or a period after the company is sold.

Keep the people who run it like you do