March 14, 2024

How Is Profit Sharing Calculated? Three Formulas

Profit sharing is calculated by setting the size of the pool a company will share, deciding who is eligible for it, and then splitting the pool between those employees using one of three formulas: comp-to-comp, flat dollar, or points. Comp-to-comp is the one most small business plans use, and you will also see it called pro rata, because dividing the pool in proportion to salary and handing each person their share of total eligible pay are the same calculation written two ways. All three are worked through below, and the profit sharing calculator will do the arithmetic if you would rather not.

With the introduction of the MARE to the small business world, many employers have questions about what the tool does and does not provide.  The MARE includes phantom equity and profit sharing tools that provide both long and short-term employee incentives. This blog post focuses on the profit sharing component, and on how each employee’s share is calculated.

Try our free profit sharing calculator

Designing Your Profit Sharing Calculator

StepWhat to do
1. Determine the size of your company’s profit sharing poolThe first step in calculating and allocating profits for each employee is to take a broader view of your business finances and decide on the size of your overall profit sharing pool.
2. Decide which employees are eligible for profit sharingSome businesses allow all employees to participate in company profit sharing plans.
3. Establish your profit sharing distribution formulaSimilar to eligibility requirements, your company’s profit sharing distribution formula will vary based on a variety of factors.

Step 1: Determine the size of your company’s profit sharing pool

The first step in calculating and allocating profits for each employee is to take a broader view of your business finances and decide on the size of your overall profit sharing pool. While a common pool size ranges from 5% to 15% of annual profits, every company is different. Some factors to take into account include your company’s general financial health, short and long term business goals, and, of course, your actual net profits.

Step 2: Decide which employees are eligible for profit sharing

Some businesses allow all employees to participate in company profit sharing plans. Some gate profit sharing for certain seniority levels or titles. Other popular eligibility requirements include a condition to meet certain performance metrics or be employed at a given company for a certain length of time before enrolling in their profit sharing program. The most important aspect of this step is to define clear eligibility criteria, regardless of what those criteria are.

Step 3: Establish your profit sharing distribution formula

Similar to eligibility requirements, your company’s profit sharing distribution formula will vary based on a variety of factors. Common inputs include job levels, tenure, and even age of individual employees. But the most common approach to standardizing a formula is to allocate shares of the profit pool based on each eligible employee’s salary. This is called a pro-rata plan, and it’s the one that is most commonly used within the MARE.

Example Formula

The default MARE profit sharing formula is:

Annual profit sharing pool divided pro rata based on relative salaries

Here’s an example of how that might play out at a small business:

Company A has net annual profits of $500,000. The company’s owner decides to allocate a profit sharing pool of 5% of the company’s annual profits, which amounts to $25,000.

The owner wants to enroll three employees in Company A’s profit sharing plan. They spend a total of $160,000 on annual compensation for these three employees. The employees’ salaries are the following:

  • Sarah: $45,000
  • Alex: $50,000
  • Chris: $65,000

Here is how each employee’s profit sharing allocation would be calculated:

  • Sarah: ($25,000/$160,000) X 45,000 = ~ $7,000
  • Alex: ($25,000/$160,000) X 50,000 = ~ $7,800
  • Chris: ($25,000/$160,000) X 65,000 =~ $10,000

In the above example, each employee receives an annual profit sharing bonus equal to approximately 15% of their compensation.

While a pro-rata salary-based formula is the most popular option with small business owners, the MARE also allows for custom performance or milestone-based profit sharing formulas.

How is profit sharing calculated?

Profit sharing is calculated by deciding the pool, then dividing it. Most disputes come from the first step, not the second.

Define the pool

The pool is normally a fixed percentage of a defined profit figure, and the word that matters is defined. Net profit before owner distributions, before or after tax, before or after debt service and before or after owner salary are all defensible choices that produce very different numbers. Write the definition into the plan document before the first payout.

Divide the pool

Three formulas cover almost every small business plan:

  • Comp-to-comp: each share equals the pool multiplied by that person’s salary divided by total payroll.
  • Flat dollar: the pool divided by headcount.
  • Points: the pool divided by total points, multiplied by each person’s points, where points come from tenure, role or both.

A worked example: a $50,000 pool across payroll of $250,000 is 20% of salary, so someone earning $70,000 receives $14,000 under comp-to-comp. The same person receives $12,500 under a flat split across four people. The formula, not the pool, is what decides whether the plan feels fair.

You've picked a formula, comp-to-comp, flat dollar, or points. In Reins' profit sharing calculator, you enter the pool and each employee's salary and it returns each person's share, so you are not running the percentages by hand for a dozen people every quarter.

What to state in writing

The profit definition, the percentage, the formula, the payment date, any vesting, and what happens to an unvested share when someone leaves. Those lines prevent almost every argument a profit sharing plan generates.

Once the formula is settled the arithmetic is the easy part, and you do not have to do it by hand: the profit sharing calculator takes the pool and the eligible salaries and returns each person’s share. Reins handles the agreements and the record keeping that sit behind whichever formula you choose.

FAQs

We set up profit sharing plans that make employees think like owners.

Book a call with a specialist